German incest couple lose European court case
By the CNN Wire Staff
April 13, 2012 — Updated 1003 GMT (1803 HKT)
- Patrick Stuebing was sent to prison for his incestuous relationship with his sister
- He lost his case that the conviction violated his right to a private and family life
- The European Court of Human Rights ruled that Germany was entitled to ban incest
- “We just want to lead a normal life,” Stuebing told CNN in a 2007 interview
Berlin (CNN) — A German man sent to prison over an incestuous relationship with his sister has lost his case that the conviction violated his right to a private and family life at the European Court of Human Rights.
Patrick Stuebing had a consensual sexual relationship with his sister after they first met when he was in his 20s and she was a teenager. They had four children, two of whom are disabled, the court said.
Stuebing lodged his case with the European Court of Human Rights after being sent to prison in November 2005 by a Leipzig court and losing subsequent appeals against his conviction for incest.
But the court ruled Thursday that the German authorities had the right to ban incest.
In convicting Stuebing, the German Federal Constitutional Court had “considered that sexual relationships between siblings could seriously damage family structures and, as a consequence, society as a whole,” the court ruled.
Stuebing, who was born in 1976 and lives in Leipzig, was adopted and grew up with no contact with his birth family after the age of seven, according to a court statement.
When he reestablished contact with his birth family in 2000, he met his sister Susan, eight years younger than him and then aged 16.
Their relationship intensified after the death of their mother, the court said, and from January 2001 they “had consensual sexual intercourse and lived together for several years.”
Their four children were born between 2001 and 2005.
Speaking to CNN’s Frederick Pleitgen in 2007, Stuebing explained that he and his sister had fallen in love, and simply wanted to have their relationship legalized.
“We just want to lead a normal life,” he said. “People harass us all the time and call us the incest couple. They have no idea who we really are or how it all happened.”
Stuebing’s sister was not prosecuted by German authorities because she was considered “only partially liable for her actions,” Thursday’s court ruling said.
The sister “suffered from a personality disorder and was considerably dependent on him,” the court said.
An appeal can be lodged against the court’s judgment, which is not final, within the next three months.
CNN’s Laura Perez Maestro contributed to this report.
Part of complete coverage on
April 13, 2012 — Updated 0049 GMT (0849 HKT)
CNN’s John Vause talks to The Ploughshares Fund president Joseph Cirincione about North Korea’s failed rocket launch.
April 12, 2012 — Updated 2351 GMT (0751 HKT)
Child actors lay bare the issues they say must be tackled the country’s leaders. In one scene, a child is robbed, in another, drug traffickers clash with police.
April 12, 2012 — Updated 1120 GMT (1920 HKT)
Some athletes will go to any lengths to get their hands on an Olympic gold medal, but drug cheats will find it harder than ever at London 2012.
April 13, 2012 — Updated 0012 GMT (0812 HKT)
Based on profits, Sony Corp. is an outstanding company — in life insurance sales and hit movies such as the “Men in Black” and “Spider-Man” franchises.
April 12, 2012 — Updated 1452 GMT (2252 HKT)
Inside the reclusive country, CNN’s Stan Grant asks just how long can the Kim dynasty hold onto power?
April 12, 2012 — Updated 0052 GMT (0852 HKT)
Egypt has suspended the country’s constitutional assembly, tasked with drafting a constitution. But what does that mean for reforms?
April 12, 2012 — Updated 0939 GMT (1739 HKT)
She was a tiny thing: 1 pound 12 ounces, cold as a frozen bottle and left for dead. But she would survive.
April 10, 2012 — Updated 0936 GMT (1736 HKT)
The legendary Hanging Gardens of Babylon are inspiration behind an ambitious plan to grow a rooftop forest high above Beirut’s crowded streets.
April 9, 2012 — Updated 1303 GMT (2103 HKT)
Former U.S. Ambassador says North Korea’s rocket launch plan masks political rivalries at the very top.
April 6, 2012 — Updated 1400 GMT (2200 HKT)
Greek businessman Apostolos Polyzonis, who survived setting himself on fire outside his bank, explains the despair that drove him.
April 9, 2012 — Updated 0524 GMT (1324 HKT)
During the Libyan war, Eman al-Obeidi stormed into a Tripoli hotel, screaming she had been raped. Now she is trying to start over in Colorado.
April 9, 2012 — Updated 1619 GMT (0019 HKT)
The answer has to do with the drama of choice, not with the brute facts of the disaster itself, argues professor Stephen D. Cox.
Vast portions of west and central Africa have become so dry that they can’t support crops, livestock and the millions of people who live there.
April 8, 2012 — Updated 1339 GMT (2139 HKT)
Paul Gilding: The demands we place on the environment exceed its capacity — and one day when economic growth will reach its limit.
April 10, 2012 — Updated 0852 GMT (1652 HKT)
For Rwanda’s national cycling team, survivors of its genocide, cycling is proving to have an unlikely healing power.
April 10, 2012 — Updated 1353 GMT (2153 HKT)
The Chinese capital is a city rich in culture, but some parts of its history are threatened by its booming modernization.
April 4, 2012 — Updated 1351 GMT (2151 HKT)
Sounds nutty, but U.S. researchers are using robot squirrels to learn more about how real ones interact with their main predator.
April 10, 2012 — Updated 1137 GMT (1937 HKT)
Top cooks turn their attention to an altogether more complex problem — rustling up gourmet airline food.
Today’s five most popular stories